Posts Tagged as: ‘STOP & THINK’

 
With this special project for EXD09, ExperimentaDesign challenges editors and critics around the world to stimulate in-depth design criticism. Serious criticism, which looks beyond the product and the producer to the cultural contexts for which design is essentially made. We invite editors of design and architecture magazines to publish their contribution to this discourse in their September issues, and will collect the essays in a book to be published at a later date. During the opening week of EXD09 - It’s About Time, participating editors will publicly discuss the reasons for joining our project.
22.03.2009
15:01

ExperimentaDesign Lisboa/Amsterdam is challenging editors of leading design, architecture and lifestyle magazines from around the world to take part in a project that aims to foster insightful design criticism today.

The need for thorough design criticism exists beyond academia. Designers and their audience profit from critical analysis that surpasses mere journalistic reporting. We need not only to know what’s out there, but also want to ask why? The current obsession with discovering the latest product, showcasing the freshest talent, reviewing the next event, and highlighting the newest buildings demonstrates that magazines often race for previews instead of reviews, and for short paragraphs instead of the big picture. Serious criticism, which looks beyond the product and the producer to the cultural contexts for which design is essentially made, is under pressure.

We invite editors and critics within the cultural and design field to do two things: first help us in developing shared criteria for in-depth design critique, and second to apply these criteria to identify subjects in need of scrutiny and formulate clear briefs for authors.

This blog will mainly serve the first purpose: to discuss what we consider good design criticism and to sharpen our criteria. Ideally, the discussions here should result in a series of state-of-the-art essays which together will provide a benchmark for current design criticism. We invite editors to publish their contribution to this discourse in the September issues of their magazines, and will collect the essays into a book which will be published at a later date.

During the opening week of EXD09 – It’s About Time, we will organize a special event in which the participating magazines will present or preview their issues containing the Stop&Think essays, and publicly discuss the reasons for joining our project.

Please post your commentary and ideas on design criticism as comments to this post!